The Library Catalog vs. Web Searching

Is the library catalog more difficult to use than google? Why? What is the difference in the results these two types of searches return?

Tim Donahue

Banned Books Week

In the past, many books were banned in the United States by federal courts. That meant that possessing them was a federal crime, punishable by incarceration. Books are still challenged today and removed from library shelves so they are purposely unavailable for people to read. Here is a link to a list of banned or challenged books at Renne Library. Do you recognize any of the titles? We are celebrating Banned Books Week at MSU beginning Monday, Sept. 29-Friday October 4 to celebrate the freedom to read and to express. What are some of the reasons certain books are banned or challenged in this country? Do you agree that these are sometimes good reasons?

Tim Donahue

The Library of Congress Classification Outline

We've been talking a bit about the structure of scholarly information, information hierarchies, and attempts to organize the universe of knowledge. The Library of Congress Classification Outline is one of those attempts. Is it successful? Nearly all the books in all the college and research libraries in the United States are organized and located using this system. Take a look at the main class headings. Is this how you would structure the universe of knowledge? Can you locate your annotated bibliography topic within the LCC outline? How close can you get?

Tim Donahue

Wikipedia and Hyper-Linked Research

Following Casey's lead, now check out your topic in Wikipedia. Does an article exist on your topic? Is it an exact match? How does it compare with what you found in the Encyclopedia Britannica? In the print version there are, of course, no links. How does the presence of hyperlinks change the nature of your research? Tim Donahue

Encyclopedia Britannica

Take a look at the Encyclopedia Britannica article most closely related to your AB topic. Examine both the online version and the print volumes when you can. Is the textual content the same? What about images? Other content? Which version, print or electronic, seems superior to you? Whether you have researched your topic in Encyclopedia Britannica or not, try answering this question: Should the library be spending money (your tuition dollars) on both the printed and electronic Encyclopedia Britannica?

Physical and Digital Research

The library is both physical and digital. You can conduct research physically inside the library building using books and other print materials, or, you can do research completely digitally using only a computer. When you are using the library website and electronic resources you are "inside" the digital library. More and more of library collections (books, periodicals, government documents, maps, etc.) are becoming digitized. Do we still need a physical library? In the future, when all books are scanned electronically and become available through the web, will we need library buildings? What are the advantages and disadvantages of physical and digital research?

The Knowledge Hierarchy

We've been talking about data, information, knowledge, understanding, wisdom and how these terms represent different levels of complexity in sources, computers, and the minds of researchers. Being college students, you are all exposed to various types of data, information, and knowledge. How and when does understanding evolve in this process? We all seemed to agree that in this hierarchy, wisdom occupies the top position. How is wisdom different from these other terms? Here are a couple more questions to stimulate discussion: Do computers possess understanding? Can college make you wiser? What do you make of these terms and their inter-relatedness? Please share your thoughts!

Tim Donahue

Knowledge, data, understanding, and information

In your comments to the last post, several of you mentioned data and understanding. How do you rank understanding, data, knowledge, and information in terms of complexity? Do these terms represent different levels of a common concept, or are they each unique, different not only in complexity, but in essence? Tim Donahue

Information and Knowledge

What is the difference between information and knowledge? Tim Donahue